Promise: Nominate someone from his list of justices to replace Antonin Scalia
Record date: February 1, 2017
Donald Trump promised to nominate someone from his list of justices to replace Antonin Scalia.
The commitment
Nominate someone from his list of justices to replace Antonin Scalia.
Published tracker status: Promise Kept
The tracker concluded that the promised outcome was substantially achieved.
PolitiFact’s update summarized the result this way: “Trump nominates Neil Gorsuch to fill empty Supreme Court seat left by Scalia”
What would satisfy the promise?
The relevant test is the outcome described in the commitment—not merely an announcement, executive order, proposal or attempt. A final assessment should identify the action taken, whether it remained in force, who was affected and whether the promised result was delivered at the scale stated.
Why this belongs in the record
Campaign promises are forward-looking claims. Preserving the original commitment beside the later result makes it possible to distinguish action from completion and partial movement from the outcome voters were offered.
Source and attribution
This entry indexes an external promise rating published by PolitiFact. The status is attributed to that tracker and should be revisited if its underlying evidence changes. Read the complete source review.